Following
on from last week’s post about the excellent soundboard recording of the Munich
Park Cafe show, I have decided to go with a similar show from later that year.
The Fineline cafe show in Minneapolis shares many similarities with the Park
Cafe show. Both are heavy with the sound of Eric Leeds, and both have long
jazzy styled jams. Of the two, the Fineline show is a shade more conventional
and a little less Madhouse sounding. Where they do differ greatly is the sound
quality of the recording. Whereas the Park Cafe was a lovely warm-sounding
soundboard, this one is very much an average audience recording, complete with
people talking over the music. However, it’s still worth a listen. This takes
place just a few weeks before the New Year’s gig with Miles Davis, and one gets
the feeling that this is a live rehearsal for that show. The band is very loose
and free with their playing, and there is a lot of improvisation going on.
5th
December 1987, Fineline Cafe, Minneapolis
The
first song isn’t a song at all. It’s a long instrumental that sounds part
soundcheck, part warm-up. It begins rather shapeless, with just some keyboard
sounds, and some drum rolls. The drum does settle to a steady beat, but it’s
quiet, and it takes quite a while for any sort of music to take shape around
it. The bass does join in and things improve at the five-minute mark when we
hear the horn for the first time. The first part of this didn’t interest me,
but I do enjoy the sound from here on in. The drumming becomes more intense as
the song progresses, and there are some stabs from the keyboard that adds
urgency to it. However, these fade back out again, and the next minute of the
song is very faint and barely moving at all. The last portion has some guitar
playing against the drums, but it is not enough to turn it into anything
memorable. There is nothing offensive about this opening part of the show, but
there’s nothing to get excited about either.
Madhouses
“Eleven” follows next, and it’s very much in keeping with the theme of this show.
Eric holds the main riff nicely, and the band chugs along behind just great.
This song would benefit the most from a quality recording, and despite all the
great playing, it is let down by the recording.
It’s no surprise that Eric Leeds is the main focus of this song, but
there is some nice guitar underneath played by Prince, and when Atlanta Bliss
gets his chance to play he adds some sharpness to the deeper sound of Eric
Leeds. There is a cheer from the crowd to acknowledge this, and then there is some
rather funky lead guitar played by Prince. I can’t stress enough how good this
could have been on a better recording, I can hear the music is great, but it’s
just let down by the recording. There are some keyboard runs that I enjoy as
well but they are a little lost in the recording. I did play it louder to try
and get more out of it, but all I got was more chatter from the crowd.
The
band segues easily into a longer deeper groove as there is further
improvisation from the keyboards and horns. The keyboard is enjoyable, and I
could have done with some more of it, but the horn solo is the main dish here,
and it doesn’t let me down. It’s not to everyone’s taste, as can be evidenced
by the crowd talking throughout, but for me, it’s worth listening to. Prince is
very subdued in this first half-hour of the show, and I have to keep reminding
myself that this is a Prince show.
The
band settles into another quiet bass groove and for the first time, Prince
makes his presence felt with some howling electric guitar. Against the
different backdrop of music, his playing seems to draw more attention and I
love what he is playing here. It is a version of Jimi Hendrix’s “Villanova Junction.”
And although it’s the shortest song we have heard tonight, it is the one that
captures my ears the most and demands I listen to it.
The
band then begin to play “Eleven” again, the horn riff now embedded deep in my
head. However, it’s only for a minute and quickly fades to nothing.
The
solo sound of Prince’s guitar playing leads us into the next song. He begins
delicately, in contrast to the “Villanova Junction,” and soon the gentle croon
of the horns and keyboard wrap around us for a version of “Just My Imagination.”
There are several classic performances of this song, and again this is another
one of my favorites. Nothing is too sharp and Prince’s guitar lures me in, and
soon I am cocooned in the warm-sounding music. Prince does take his time and
delivers us plenty of guitar in the first half of the song before it
inexplicably fades out. Of course, it’s the recording that fades out, not the
band, but it’s one of those frustrating moments we sometimes get when listening
to bootlegs. The recording does pick up again, and even though Prince is
playing well, the recording itself has lost momentum for me. That aside though,
Prince’s playing is so good at this stage, that I still find the last few
minutes of the song to be amongst my favorite recordings of all time, Prince is
playing with a quiet passion and intensity that I have rarely heard on any
other recording. It’s far from perfect but for me, it’s a moment of genius and
something I will come back to again and again. And that is high praise indeed
for a grubby-sounding audience recording. It’s pretty hard to follow a Prince
solo like that, but the keyboard gives it a good go. It’s not great, but it’s
just as enjoyable as anything else on this recording.
The
next song is listed as “bass solo,” and although I would call the first half a
bass solo in the conventional sense, the second part of the song is little more
than the bass and drum playing beats off one another. The first half though is
again very enjoyable without ever reaching great. The bass has a good pop to
it, and I did find myself bobbing along to it. But it was only a couple of
minutes, and by the time I was just getting into it, it was fading out again.
Still, it shows off another side to the band and added some variety and color to
the gig.
Next
is a straightforward rendition of Miles Davis’s “Freddie Freeloader.” It’s a
firm pointer to what is coming in the next few weeks when he will join the band
for the New Year’s show. It’s fairly low-key and gives the audience plenty of
time to carry on their conversations. The audience does briefly quieten when
Prince begins his guitar runs, but soon they lose interest and return to their
chatting, much to the detriment of the recording. Lucky there are a few moments
when Prince leans hard on the guitar and gets some loud sound from it which
drowns out the audience, although briefly. And surprisingly after Prince has
finished his moment there is a piano solo and the crowd is reasonably quiet throughout.
It’s a perfectly acceptable jazzy flavored solo with a couple of flourishes to
color it. Eric then returns with Atlanta Bliss and it’s the two horns that take
us through the second part of the song, firstly the trumpet, and then the deep
honk of Eric Leeds as a full stop.
I do
a double-take as I hear the melody of “Jack U Off.” But to his credit, it’s
played with a twist here, there are plenty of horns on it, and it’s got a much
bluesier sound. It’s still up-tempo and quick but has a more grown-up feel to
it with the horns on it. The guitar is barely heard at all, and there is a horn
solo instead of a guitar solo. The keyboards too play a very fast break and I
am liking them a lot before Prince picks up a guitar and the more familiar
electric sound returns to the song. His guitar break isn’t as furious as on
record, but it does have a looser feel to it, and it is a lot more mature.
The
drum solo that follows is almost obligatory sounding. It doesn’t in my opinion
add anything to the show, and it almost seems that they are just giving the
Shelia E something in payment for all the moments the rest of the band got to
solo. Anyone who reads this regularly knows that I am not a great one for drum
solos, and this one fails to change my standing on that. Sure, there are plenty
of fine skills to admire, and I do find myself nodding along to it, but it’s
not what I signed up for. So I listen appreciatively until the next song
starts. Things surge again as the drum solo ends, and there is one more very
fast and furious reprise of “Jack U Off,” lead by the horns. And when I say
fast and furious I mean it, this one flies along at breakneck speed until the
sudden end gives us all a chance to catch our breath.
“Chain
Of Fools” is recognizable right from the start as the guitar plays the main
melody. The horns interject with the “Cold Sweat” riff, but this song is all
about that guitar. The lead guitar plays out the melody and then branches out
into more interesting territory. It’s got a fantastic tone to it, and I can’t
help but again wish that this was a soundboard. Oh well, it is what it is. Not
to be outshone the horns then again come on board, and they too add another
dimension to it. They aren’t too sharp and play along over the main groove.
There is some funky guitar at this stage, but it’s just holding the groove
while the horns play. It gets its moment again soon as the horns step back and
some slow smokey guitar sounds are heard. What is great about this gig is how
the musicians play off each other. Whenever Prince plays a solo on the guitar,
the horns come up with something in the same vein that pushes it even further.
There is a deep smokey guitar solo, followed by a similar sounding horn solo that
by the end of it has doubled the intensity. It’s a wonder to listen to.
The
music pulls back a little and we very gently move into “Housequake.” It’s not
immediately apparent, as it’s a very gradual transition from “Chain Of Fools.”
Eventually, Prince is on the mic whispering “almost there, shut up already”
It’s a cool moment, but even then the song doesn’t kick into “Housequake”
proper. The deep groove continues, and it’s only after another minute we hear
the kicking beat of “Housequake.” There is a further horn solo while the crowd
can be heard chanting “shut up already” Even with the “Housequake” beat it
would be hard to describe this as a version of “Housequake.” It’s an extension
of the previous song, with some more horn and the Housequake beat only features
a few times, before making a much stronger appearance near the end of the song.
There is a horn refrain thrown in too, and I am greatly disappointed when the
recording abruptly ends.
So,
what to make of this show? Last week I gushed about the Park Cafe show, for all
its quality and musicality. After relistening to this one, and considering, I
would have to say that this one would be its equal if it had have been recorded
in the same manner. Unfortunately, it’s not, the recording is nowhere near as
good. So I can only go by what I have. This is one of several shows I have that
are simply amazing but recorded in poor condition. I highly rate this show, and
thoroughly recommend it to anyone who enjoyed the Park Cafe show, and can
stomach an audience recording. This show is one of the reasons why I don’t
dismiss audience recordings, there are some fantastic shows out there if you
can suffer through the dropouts and chatter. This one is not for the faint-hearted
but is still highly recommended.
Next
week I will finish this trilogy of shows, Park Cafe, Fineline cafe, with the
New Year show with Miles Davis. These last two shows seem to point naturally
enough in that direction, and an evening with Miles Davis seems a fitting way
to end the year.